Firestarter SEO vs Mad Fish Digital

A head-to-head comparison of Firestarter SEO and Mad Fish Digital in seo agencies, scored across the same 5 weighted criteria so you can see exactly where each agency is stronger.

Firestarter SEO

AI-first SEO and PPC growth partner for small businesses and local service brands.

73/ 100 overall

Mad Fish Digital

Award-winning digital marketing for purpose-driven brands.

77/ 100 overallHigher score

Score-by-score

Criterion	Firestarter SEO	Mad Fish Digital
Website Presence(20%)	88	86
Search Visibility(20%)	62	58
Trust & Credibility(20%)	72	84
Market Presence(15%)	70	74
Customer Satisfaction(10%)	68	88
Overall	73	77

Pricing at a glance

Firestarter SEO

Model: Primarily monthly retainer SEO, with publicly posted monthly SEO package tiers and separate local SEO monthly plans; PPC is billed as a flat monthly management fee based on campaign scope, with ad spend paid directly to the platform. Custom quotes are offered for multi-location, franchise, and higher-competition engagements.
Typical range: $800-$3,500/month

Full Firestarter SEO pricing →

Mad Fish Digital

Model: Custom-quoted digital marketing engagements, most consistent with a monthly retainer and/or ongoing scoped services, with some project-based work also possible. Evidence: Mad Fish describes recurring 30-day client reporting/strategy meetings and offers ongoing SEO, PPC, content, paid media, social, consulting, and design services rather than fixed packages.
Typical range: $150 - $199 / hr

Full Mad Fish Digital pricing →

Firestarter SEO profile →Mad Fish Digital profile →← All seo agencies