An independent, evidence-based evaluation of Mad Fish Digital, award-winning digital marketing for purpose-driven brands.. Scored across 5 weighted criteria covering website presence, search visibility, trust, market presence, and customer satisfaction.
Overall evaluation score
The agency helps purpose-driven brands align what they stand for with how they perform in the market by blending strategy, data, systems thinking, and channel execution to drive measurable growth and lasting impact.
Weight: 20%
Mad Fish Digital has a substantial website presence based on the evidence: a detailed homepage, About, Contact, FAQ, Privacy Policy, and multiple service pages covering SEO, paid media, strategy, content, and design, plus clear contact details (address, phone, email), though no broader site-depth or performance evidence was provided.
Weight: 20%
Search visibility evidence is limited and therefore scored conservatively: the domain madfishdigital.com is about 12 years old and the homepage was reportedly updated in October 2025, but no traffic, rankings, backlink, keyword, or directory visibility metrics were included in the bundle.
Weight: 20%
Trust and credibility are strong from the provided evidence because the firm has verifiable business details (Portland address, phone, email, founded 2005, team size 11-50, LinkedIn presence), a BBB profile with an A+ rating, and positive third-party reviews on Clutch, G2, and Capterra, although BBB accreditation is absent and review volume is still modest.
Weight: 15%
Mad Fish Digital shows a solid but not dominant market presence based on its 2005 founding date, LinkedIn company page, listings/reviews across Clutch, G2, Capterra, BBB, and directory mentions such as DesignRush and GoodFirms, but the evidence does not include larger-scale footprint indicators like broad media coverage, major awards verification, or strong search/distribution metrics.
Weight: 10%
Customer satisfaction appears high because the review evidence is consistently positive across Clutch (4.9/5 from 10 reviews), G2 (4.5/5 from 1 review), and Capterra (5/5 from 3 reviews), with visible praise for communication, professionalism, responsiveness, customer service, and quality of work, offset slightly by one noted concern around employee turnover/service continuity.
Mad Fish Digital offers integrated digital marketing services for purpose-driven organizations, combining strategic consulting with performance execution and creative support.
Research-based SEO strategies designed to help brands be present when their audience is searching for them.
Paid media and digital advertising services focused on meeting audiences where they are and supporting lead generation and growth.
Content strategy and content marketing built to tell stories audiences care about and support brand growth.
Social media services aimed at helping brands build community and strengthen audience engagement.
Creative and design services intended to help brands make a strong first impression.
Consulting support for strategic decision-making and answering complex marketing questions.
Mad Fish Digital does not appear to publish self-serve prices, plans, or packages on its own site; pricing seems custom and quote-based. The clearest concrete figures are from third-party directories: Clutch lists a $5,000+ minimum project size and $150-$199/hr average hourly rate, while DesignRush lists a minimal budget of $1,000-$10,000; these are directory-reported figures, not a price sheet published by Mad Fish itself. Clutch also summarizes verified client investments ranging from $3,000 to $300,000, which is useful spend context but not a formal menu price.
Where this pricing information was traced from.
Mad Fish Digital has a clear third-party review presence on Clutch, G2, Capterra, and BBB, but I could not locate a matching Trustpilot profile or a confirmed Google listing/profile in search results for this analysis. Where review text was actually visible, the company is described positively overall, with praise centered on communication, professionalism, customer service, strategy quality, and responsiveness; the only notable criticism I could verify from platform summaries was occasional employee turnover/service continuity concerns.
10 reviews
Clutch reviewers consistently praise Mad Fish Digital for strong communication, professionalism, and high-quality strategic work. Review highlights also mention smooth collaboration and understanding client needs, while noting some concerns about employee turnover.
“They were very knowledgeable and professional and responded to emails in a timely manner.”
“Mad Fish Digital is consistent in terms of communication and delivery.”
“I feel that my business matters to them and we’re being taken care of.”
“I was impressed by their quality of work, transparency, and knowledge.”
1 reviews
The lone visible G2 review is strongly positive and emphasizes customer service, availability, knowledgeable staff, modern design/development capabilities, and reasonable pricing. I only found one visible review for this company on G2.
“The best thing about Mad Fish Digital is their commitment to customer service.”
“They are always available to answer questions, provide guidance, and offer suggestions to ensure the best possible outcome for the project.”
3 reviews
Capterra shows Mad Fish Digital as a listed design/digital marketing agency in Portland with a 5.0 rating from 3 reviews. However, in the search results/page text I could access, I could not read any individual review wording, so I cannot provide grounded excerpts.
BBB has a business profile for Mad Fish Digital in Portland, Oregon, showing the business as not BBB accredited and assigning it an A+ BBB rating. In the material visible here, I could confirm the profile exists, but I could not confirm visible customer review text or review counts.
Strengths
Concerns
The madfishdigital.com domain was registered in October 2013 (~12 years old), with the homepage last modified October 2025. Figures are from a live RDAP domain lookup and HTTP headers, not estimated.
Domain registered
October 2013
Last updated
October 2025
Domain age
~12 years